Schools vs. Social Media – Who Teaches Us More?
Insights from the 251st Episode of BLUB World Web Talks
In today's rapidly evolving digital landscape, the debate between traditional schooling and social media as sources of education is more relevant than ever. The 251st episode of BLUB World Web Talks brought together educators, students, and thought leaders to explore this pressing question:
Who teaches us more – schools or social media?
The discussion featured compelling arguments from both sides, providing invaluable insights into the future of learning. Here’s a breakdown of the key takeaways from this thought-provoking global edition.
The Great Debate: Schools vs. Social Media
The session kicked off with a fundamental question: In a world where content consumption has transformed, do we learn more from schools or social media? With over 4,000 school leaders having participated in past episodes, this global edition focused on how the learning landscape is shifting.
Dr. Deepti Chaturvedi, Founder Principal of Silicon City International School, set the stage by highlighting the human-centric approach of schools. She emphasized that while social media provides an abundance of information, schools ensure quality education and a safe environment. “When faced with a problem, teens don’t turn to social media; they seek guidance from parents, teachers, or elders,” she noted, reinforcing the idea that schools offer structured learning and emotional support.
On the other hand, Srishti Sanjay, a Grade 11 student, passionately defended social media as a powerful educational tool. She argued that platforms like Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok expose students to real-world issues, diverse perspectives, and unfiltered truths often missing in textbooks. “Social media isn’t just education; it’s an awakening,” she declared, challenging the conventional limits of classroom learning.
The Teen Perspective: Social Media as a Game-Changer
Teenagers like Shingo, a Grade 10 student from Rwanda, and Arfa Zoya, a Grade 8 student from India, echoed Srishti’s sentiments. They pointed out that social media offers real-time knowledge, engaging lessons, and practical skills that traditional schooling often lacks.
Shingo emphasized that platforms like YouTube provide interactive and entertaining lessons from experts like Mark Rober (a former NASA engineer) and Dr. Mattu (a medical educator), making complex subjects more accessible.
Ara Zoya added a humorous touch: “Next time someone tells you to get off your phone and study, just say, ‘I’m learning on social media!’” Her remark underscored the growing role of social media as a go-to educational resource.
The Educators’ Stand: Schools as the Foundation
While students championed social media, educators like Mrs. Salma Aratan and Mrs. Anna Matanga stressed the irreplaceable role of schools. They argued that schools offer structured curricula, emotional intelligence, and accountability that social media often lacks.
Mrs. Aratan pointed out that social media can spread misinformation and distractions, whereas schools provide a safe, guided environment for learning. Mrs. Matanga reinforced this by stating that teachers nurture discipline, perseverance, and social skills—qualities essential for long-term success that no algorithm can replicate.
Finding the Middle Ground: Balancing Both Worlds
The discussion also highlighted the need for a balanced approach. Abdul Alim, a Grade 8 student from India, summed it up perfectly: “Social media provides information, but schools provide education.” He emphasized that while social media can enhance learning, teachers shape character, values, and discipline—something technology cannot replace.
Similarly, Shol Fernando, a student from Sri Lanka, argued that schools provide depth and accountability, while social media offers breadth and immediacy. He suggested that schools should teach students how to critically navigate social media, while digital platforms can supplement traditional learning with fresh perspectives.
Key Takeaways: Who Wins the Debate?
Schools Teach Better, But Social Media Teaches More – Schools offer structured, quality education, while social media provides an ever-evolving pool of knowledge.
Emotional Intelligence vs. Raw Information – Schools nurture emotional and social growth, while social media delivers fast-paced, unfiltered content.
The Need for Balance – The future of education lies in integrating the strengths of both, using social media as a complementary tool.
Accountability Matters – Schools take responsibility for students’ development, while social media often lacks regulation and reliability.
Final Thoughts: The Future of Learning
The 251st episode of BLUB World Web Talks left us with a crucial takeaway: Education is not about choosing between schools and social media but about leveraging the best of both worlds.
As we move forward, the challenge lies in fostering synergy between traditional education and digital platforms, ensuring students receive a holistic, engaging, and meaningful learning experience.
What’s Your Take?
Who do you think teaches more – schools or social media? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and stay tuned for more insightful discussions in the upcoming episodes of BLUB World Web Talks!
For more thought-provoking discussions, explore our Blub World Web Talks Playlist on YouTube.
Call to Action:
Join the conversation! Share your thoughts on who teaches you more – schools or social media – in the comments below. Subscribe now for more updates on BLUB World Web Talks!
Comments